Skip to main content

IHR Advisors represents individuals and families in cases involving arbitrary detention around the world, including applications to the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD).

The Working Group investigates cases in which a person may have been deprived of their liberty arbitrarily or in breach of applicable international human rights standards. Cases can involve political imprisonment, detention following the exercise of fundamental rights, serious failures of due process, prolonged immigration detention and discriminatory detention.

Our international human rights lawyers advise on whether a case falls within the Working Group’s mandate, prepare submissions and supporting evidence, and represent clients throughout the procedure.

What is the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention?

The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention is a United Nations human rights mechanism made up of independent experts.

Its mandate includes investigating individual cases of deprivation of liberty alleged to be arbitrary or inconsistent with international human rights standards.

Information about an individual case can be submitted by the person concerned, their family or representatives, as well as other organisations.

Following its consideration of an individual case, the Working Group can issue an opinion determining whether the deprivation of liberty is arbitrary and recommending steps to remedy the violation.

When can detention be considered arbitrary?

The Working Group considers cases under five categories.

Category I: No legal basis for the detention

Category I applies where it is clearly impossible to identify a legal basis justifying the deprivation of liberty. This can include, for example, continued detention after a sentence has expired or despite an applicable amnesty.

Category II: Detention for exercising fundamental rights

Category II concerns detention resulting from the legitimate exercise of rights protected by international human rights law. Depending on the circumstances, this can include freedom of expression, religion, peaceful assembly and association, political participation and freedom of movement. Cases involving journalists, political opponents, activists, human rights defenders and others targeted because of the lawful exercise of fundamental freedoms may fall within this category.

Category III: Serious violations of the right to a fair trial

Detention may fall within Category III where failures to observe international fair-trial standards are sufficiently serious to make the resulting deprivation of liberty arbitrary. The assessment depends on the circumstances of the case and the gravity of the violations. Issues can include access to legal representation, the independence and impartiality of the tribunal, the ability to challenge evidence and other fundamental due-process protections.

Category IV: Prolonged detention of migrants, asylum seekers or refugees

Category IV concerns asylum seekers, immigrants and refugees subjected to prolonged administrative detention without the possibility of meaningful administrative or judicial review or remedy.

Category V: Discriminatory detention

Category V applies where detention violates international law because it is based on discrimination and is aimed at, or capable of resulting in, a denial of equality. Relevant grounds can include nationality, ethnic or social origin, religion, political or other opinion, gender, sexual orientation, disability or another protected status.

More than one category can be relevant to the same case.

How do you make a complaint to the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention?

A case begins with a detailed submission setting out the circumstances of the detention and explaining why it falls within the Working Group’s mandate.

This requires more than showing that an arrest, prosecution or detention is considered unfair. The submission needs to identify the relevant international human rights standards, establish the facts and evidence, and explain how those facts engage one or more of the Working Group’s categories of arbitrary detention.

The Working Group’s procedure allows it to communicate allegations to the government concerned and consider the government’s response before reaching its opinion. The procedure is conducted primarily in writing.

What evidence is needed for a WGAD application?

The evidence required will depend on the case. A submission may need to address:

  • the identity and circumstances of the detained person;
  • the date, place and circumstances of arrest;
  • the legal basis claimed for the detention;
  • charges and criminal proceedings;
  • court decisions and procedural history;
  • access to lawyers and family members;
  • evidence concerning the fairness of proceedings;
  • political statements or other evidence relevant to the motivation for the detention;
  • discrimination or targeting based on a protected characteristic;
  • domestic attempts to challenge the detention; and
  • relevant medical or detention information.

The objective is to present a clear factual chronology supported by available evidence and connect it to the applicable international legal framework.

Does the Working Group have an urgent procedure?

Yes. The Working Group has an urgent action procedure for appropriate cases where sufficiently reliable allegations indicate that urgent intervention may be required.

Urgent action is distinct from the Working Group’s regular procedure. An urgent appeal does not determine whether detention is arbitrary and does not prejudge any opinion the Working Group may later issue.

A case may subsequently be considered under the regular procedure so that the Working Group can determine whether the deprivation of liberty is arbitrary.

What can the Working Group do?

After considering an individual case, the Working Group may adopt an opinion on whether the deprivation of liberty is arbitrary.

Where it finds a violation, it can recommend appropriate steps to remedy the situation.

Depending on the circumstances, its recommendations may address release, compensation or other forms of reparation, investigation and changes required to bring laws or practices into conformity with international standards.

The Working Group is not a domestic court and its procedure should not be confused with an appeal against a national conviction or detention order. Its opinions and recommendations form part of the United Nations human rights system and can nevertheless be significant in international advocacy, diplomatic engagement and wider legal strategies.

Do I need to exhaust domestic remedies before approaching the WGAD?

The Working Group is an international mechanism with its own procedures and should not simply be treated as another level of domestic appeal.

Whether and when a case should be submitted requires consideration of the domestic proceedings, other international procedures and the overall legal strategy.

IHR Advisors can assess the available routes and advise on how a WGAD application may interact with domestic proceedings and other international human rights mechanisms.

How IHR Advisors can help

Cases before the Working Group can involve complex questions of international law, evidence, domestic criminal proceedings and political context.

IHR Advisors advises clients on:

  • whether detention may fall within one or more WGAD categories;
  • case strategy and the timing of an application;
  • preparation of the factual and evidential record;
  • drafting and filing submissions;
  • responses to government observations;
  • urgent action where appropriate;
  • coordination with domestic lawyers and international advisers; and
  • the use of a WGAD opinion within a wider legal and international strategy.

Our lawyers work on international human rights, politically motivated prosecutions, INTERPOL and extradition matters across jurisdictions. This allows us to consider arbitrary detention alongside related international proceedings rather than in isolation.

Our cases before the Working Group and the UN Special Rapporteurs

The cases below come from the international law practice of Ben Keith and Rhys Davies at IHR Advisors. For many detained clients, a Working Group opinion is the first independent ruling on their case. In 2025, the Working Group adopted 78 opinions concerning 210 people. Sixty-six of them were later released.

Ryan Cornelius, UAE (Opinion No. 19/2022)

Ryan Cornelius, a British businessman, was stopped at Dubai airport in May 2008. He was hooded and held for ten days without a lawyer, then told to sign a statement in Arabic, a language he could not read. In 2011, a Dubai court convicted him of embezzling state funds, in a case that grew out of a financing dispute with Dubai Islamic Bank, and sentenced him to ten years. In March 2018, two months before that term was due to end, a judge added twenty years at the bank’s request under Dubai Law No. 37 of 2009. That law took effect after his arrest. The Bahrain Chamber for Dispute Resolution has held that the debt to the bank was already discharged.

Ben Keith and Rhys Davies acted pro bono. The UAE did not reply to the Working Group, which adopted Opinion No. 19/2022 at its 93rd session in April 2022. It found the detention arbitrary under Categories I and III, in breach of eight articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and called for his immediate release.

On 24 July 2026, more than four years later, Matthew Gillett, Chair-Rapporteur of the Working Group, joined Alice Jill Edwards, Special Rapporteur on torture, and Tlaleng Mofokeng, Special Rapporteur on the right to health, to warn that his detention risked becoming “a death sentence”. They noted that he had spent seven weeks in solitary confinement. Ben Keith has made Magnitsky-style sanctions submissions to every Foreign Secretary since Liz Truss. Mr Cornelius is 72 and remains in prison.

Charles Ridley, UAE (Opinion No. 43/2025)

Charles Ridley is Ryan Cornelius’s business partner. He was arrested in Dubai in May 2008 by at least twelve plain-clothes men who had no warrant. They blindfolded him, and he was held in isolation for several weeks. In 2011, he was convicted of embezzling state funds and sentenced to ten years and a $500 million fine.

His sentence ended in November 2015, but he was not released. In May 2018, Dubai Islamic Bank obtained an additional twenty years against him under Law No. 37 of 2009, which allows a creditor to keep a prisoner in custody over an unpaid debt. The bank did this despite a Bahraini judgment that the debt had been discharged, a point the UAE has never contested.

The UAE did not reply to the Working Group in this case either. Opinion No. 43/2025, adopted on 26 August 2025, found the detention arbitrary under Categories I and III. A 2009 law had been applied to conduct from 2004 to 2007. He received no notice of the 2018 hearings, had no chance to defend himself, and had no right of appeal. The Working Group called for his immediate release and compensation, and said the UAE should review the law to avoid “debt-detention traps”. Ben Keith, Barrister and Co-Founder of IHR Advisors, said the international community “must now exert pressure to secure his immediate release”.

Zack Shahin, UAE and Yemen (Opinion No. 76/2022)

Zack Shahin, an American citizen, is a former PepsiCo executive who later ran the Dubai developer Deyaar. On 23 March 2008, he was arrested at gunpoint at the Ruler’s Court, without a warrant, and held incommunicado for 17 days. He was deprived of sleep, food and water. He was tried as a “government employee”, which exposed him to heavier penalties, although the Dubai government’s own legal department had confirmed in writing that Deyaar was not affiliated to the government. His sentences came to 25 years. Another twenty were added under Law No. 37 of 2009, applied retroactively.

Released on bail in 2012, he received death threats and left for Yemen. On 1 September 2012, Yemeni officials, apparently under the control of a liaison officer from the UAE Embassy in Sana’a, seized him and forced him onto a flight to Dubai.

Ben Keith and Rhys Davies were instructed in October 2021 and worked with Detained International on the #FreeUSAZack campaign. Neither state replied to the Working Group. Opinion No. 76/2022 found against both. Yemen’s detention of Mr Shahin was arbitrary under Categories I and III, because he was handed over with no legal basis and no extradition process. The UAE’s detention was declared arbitrary under Categories I, III and V. He had been arrested without a warrant, held incommunicado and sentenced under a law that post-dated the alleged conduct, and there were credible allegations that he had been tortured. Category V reflects discrimination against him as a non-national. The Working Group referred the case to the Special Rapporteur on torture and called for his immediate release and reparations.

Mariam Abdelbasette and Ahmed Mousa, Egypt and Oman

Mariam Abdelbasette is an Egyptian activist who was living in Oman, where she shared posts for an online opposition movement. On 9 April 2026, Oman deported her husband, Ahmed Mousa, to Egypt. He disappeared on arrival. Six days later, she was stopped at the airport and told that Egypt had her “listed on INTERPOL”. No notice or warrant was ever produced. She learned that she was a defendant in an Egyptian state security case from photographs of the case file, sent to her by strangers. After giving birth, she was held under guard in a military hospital in Muscat, with “prisoner” on her chart.

On 5 May 2026, Ben Keith and Cristian González Ruiz applied to the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF). They also sent an urgent request to the Special Rapporteur on torture. Working with the Law and Democracy Support Foundation, we prepared the submission behind the joint letter that six UN mandate holders sent to Egypt and Oman on 18 June 2026. It asked where Mr Mousa was and what Egypt had asked INTERPOL to do. After that, she could not be deported quietly. In September 2026, Oman let her leave with her children.

Speak to our international human rights lawyers

If you or a family member is detained and you believe the detention may be arbitrary or politically motivated, IHR Advisors can assess whether the case may fall within the mandate of the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention.

Contact IHR Advisors

Frequently asked questions

What does WGAD stand for?

WGAD stands for the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. It investigates cases in which deprivation of liberty may be arbitrary or inconsistent with applicable international human rights standards.

Who can submit a case to the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention?

Information can be provided by the individual concerned, their family or representatives and other relevant organisations. The submission should provide sufficient factual and legal information for the Working Group to consider the case.

What are the five categories of arbitrary detention?

The Working Group uses five categories covering detention without a legal basis; detention resulting from the exercise of protected rights; sufficiently serious fair-trial violations; prolonged detention of asylum seekers, immigrants or refugees without meaningful review or remedy; and discriminatory detention.

Can the WGAD order someone’s release?

The Working Group can determine that detention is arbitrary and recommend measures to remedy the violation, which may include release. It is not a domestic court with its own enforcement machinery.

Can the WGAD consider politically motivated detention?

Yes. Depending on the facts, politically motivated detention can engage several parts of the Working Group’s framework, including detention resulting from the exercise of protected rights, serious fair-trial violations and discrimination based on political or other opinion.

Does the WGAD have an urgent procedure?

Yes. The Working Group can use an urgent action procedure in appropriate cases. An urgent appeal is humanitarian in nature and does not prejudge the Working Group’s eventual opinion under its regular procedure.

Contact details

If you would like to speak with us about our areas of practice or anything else please contact us via the form linked below.

Contact Us